Seemingly Hallucinating Analytics

So I use Fullres for more in-depth analytics on page views and the like but also check Ghost’s internal analytics for things like click rates on emails and links etc. However, I just noticed that mine seem to just be well, making stuff up and I have no idea why.

Case in point, this morning I put up a new game review post. Literally right after hitting publish, I’m taken to the post’s analytics screen and see this:

This is literally within seconds of me hitting the button to publish the post, to a hobby blog that doesn’t get much traffic and just got out of Google search jail after over a year and a half. It’s saying the link to the post itself has been clicked more times than the entire site has had page views in a week and so quickly after publishing that most of the emails to my 70 subscribers wouldn’t have fully delivered yet. These numbers have also not changed since.

When I look back at my last few posts, I see a similar trend but the numbers are also different on each one.

Maybe I’m missing something but this looks like it’s basically just making stuff up. Has anyone seen this before? I’m running the latest version of self-hosted Ghost as of two days ago.

Thanks.

Hmm, at first glance I’d guess this is likely due to automated link checkers that automatically scan all links in an email once it’s delivered. Most do this by actually making a full http request to the link in the email, which gets picked up by Ghost’s analytics tracking.

We’ve applied some changes recently on Ghost(Pro) to mitigate this (mainly from a load perspective) but we’ll look and see what we can fix on the Ghost side to reduce the automated analytics noise :grimacing:

2 Likes

I thought it might be that but it’s still strange for a few reasons:

  • If it was automated link scanning, wouldn’t the count be the same for all the links?
  • The link count still varies wildly between posts.
  • Some links have been visited far more than the page has or even the blog as a whole has, at least according to Fullres.
  • This happened so fast after publishing that I don’t think most of the emails would have even flowed to the subscriber mailboxes yet, much less check by link validators.

I could see a certain amount of it being noise as you say but do these other points not seem odd too?

Are you able to analyze the access logs coming to paths starts with /r/? If this is the result of some automated requests, you should be able to see their IPs and -hopefully- user agents.

1 Like

I’m seeing the same issue across multiple installs as well. Always a LOT more clicks on the “View in browser” than anything else in there, the rest of the clicks seem relatively organic (although definitely a few bots in each). I’ve extracted some useful User Agents and IPs from the first few minutes after a send, which appear to point to things like Microsoft SafeLinks. Is there somewhere I might share them a little more secure than straight into the forum? I think they’re mostly bots but I don’t love dropping access IPs into public just in case they’re not!