I have both a public newsletter, and a separate private newsletter that’s only for the organizing committee of our organization. At the moment (and I swear this wasn’t always the case, but no matter), the private list is showing up as an option for all public subscribers on the “Choose your newsletters” page during the sign-up flow. It’s defaulting to off, but they are able to turn it on. Is there any way to make it completely hidden from the public sign-up flow, so subscription to that list is only managed by me in the back end?
I know I can sort of do this using labels on the main list, rather than having a separate list, but that way doesn’t let me run with a different template and other newsletter settings.
+1 I am also having this issue, which can create a confusing user flow especially when trying to create invite only tiers (i.e. not only do new subscribers see what should otherwise be a hidden newsletter, but when they try to “upgrade”, there is no plan for them to select). Any existing workarounds?
I’m also looking for a solution to this, has anyone found a way? I have two newsletters where the membership is managed by a script that adds or removes people based on their RSVP to an event invite. I don’t want these to show as options for sign ups to users.
Also looking for a solution to this as well. I need a private newsletter for press release-type emails, that I don’t want anyone to be able to sign up for. Is there a way to keep the newsletter hidden?
This is indeed an absolute must-have. I would also need to be able to create private newsletters (that’s useful in B2B), that are not visible to existing subscribers.
It seems we’ve had no official response on this one for 8 months — even just to confirm that this is currently expected behaviour. Would there be any more likelihood of it being noticed if I crossposted this to Ideas? I could happily work on a PR for it, if there was some indication there’d be interest in accepting it.