If “Allow free member signup” is enabled, when I hit subscribe button with new email address, sends an email with "Complete your sign up " subject. so far so good!
But in case “Allow free member signup” is disabled, when I hit subscribe button with new email address, mail is not being sent. I do get a success message saying " Great! Check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription" I have tried different email domains with no luck.
Enable members - Enabled
Connect to Stripe - I have my Stripe API and secret key enabled.
Allow free member signup - Disabled
Email Configuration - Custom SMTP server
Is there anything I am missing here?
Thanks for the help!