Welcome page not loading for members?

I am trying to get the welcome page to work when people sign up to my website. I followed the documentation that ghosts provides on how to do this, but nothing happens.

The user just stays on the home page. Has anyone had any luck with trying to get this to work?

I want my members to be greeted with the welcome page once they subscribe.
Thank you for any help!

In my limited experience so far, I’ve only gotten it to work if using a Sign Up form, not a newsletter subscribe form. Hope that helps. It should work for both in my opinion, but ¯\(ツ)