Fill out the following bug report template with as much detail as possible!
Are you sure this is a bug? If you just need help, post in the developer help category. If it’s a feature request, head to the ideas category.
On a number of sites, I’m seeing new behavior where a Ghost offer link partially opens the Portal modal, but then redirects to Stripe before showing the offer details to users:
For instance this offer:
Not sure if this is expected behaivor or not, but it seems new
Does it have anything to do with the solution someone suggested in this thread?
I think you are correct here. Appreciate you finding this.
I don’t love the experience and would love to have offers show in the modal, even if other portal links are turned off because the Stripe offer page has limited info and no real upsell compared to the Ghost modal
A workaround might be to turn the portal button on but hide it. (Just need a little css.)
It would be amazing for it to show in the tier the offer is for in the membership options, as opposed to operating like a separate purchase. Say you are offering a membership at $10/month but running a promo for $5/month for Black Friday… it would be cool for the $10 to be crossed out and $5 to show there… or even just a straightforward way to input a promo code… maybe asking for too much. 
We solved this by having Portal be technically on, but suppress showing it on the site. That way Ghost offers still show on the site, rather than bumping through to Stripe.
What do you mean here by Ghost offers still showing on the site?
I’m currently showing an offer in two ways (1) with an announcement banner and (2) by creating a product card which is displayed below my membership tier options on a custom theme membership page.
So it’s at least shown on the same page, but the offer isn’t integrated with the tier selection, which would be ideal.