Public preview not blocking content (Solved)

This seems so basic, but it’s not working, so I’m asking for help.

I have a post with a video at the top, and the transcript below. I want the video to be publicly available, but the transcript only for paying members. So, I did this:

Set the access to “paid members only.”
Put the public preview card between the video and transcript.

However, when I preview the page (haven’t published yet), all the content is visible publicly, even in an incognito window. I tried removing the public preview, and all the content is still visible.

Do you have to actually publish the post for the access and public preview card to work? Or is something else going on?

Yep, exactly. Once you publish, the content will be restricted as expected.